1. Car Reviews
  2. …
  3. BMW
  4. BMW 4 Series Convertible Review

BMW 4 Series Convertible Review

Andrew Brady

Written By Andrew Brady

 
The BMW 4 Series Convertible combines genuine four-seat usability with strong refinement and rewarding handling, although prices rise quickly.
  • 2021
  • Convertible
  • Petrol, mild hybrid petrol

What we love

  • Genuinely enjoyable to drive

  • Comfortable and refined with the roof up

  • More practical than most convertibles

Things to consider

  • Expensive, particularly the M440i

  • Rear seats are tight for taller adults

  • Mercedes CLE Cabriolet feels more comfort focused

The DRIVE take on the BMW 4 Series, is it the right car for you?

The BMW 4 Series Convertible is one of the best open four-seat cars available, combining fresh air with everyday comfort, practicality and performance.

Despite our weather, we love convertibles in the UK and while there are plenty of two-seat sports cars around, there are fewer options if you want four seats and some practicality.

Four-seat convertibles always look like a great option. After all, who doesn’t want to be able to share the open-top, wind-in-your-hair experience of a convertible with friends?

The trouble is those back seats often don’t have much legroom, so unless you are just driving your friends home from a night out, they aren’t going to be so friendly after having their limbs squashed in.

The BMW 4 Series Convertible and the 3 Series before it have always been popular choices, providing reasonable legroom for those in the back unless a tall adult is in the driver’s seat. It’s a potential family car option too, with room for the kids, decent space in the boot and a good level of comfort.

The latest generation of BMW 4 Series Convertible arrived in 2019 and with it came the buck-toothed grille. We don’t mind saying that we aren’t fans, but we are getting used to it and one person’s ugly is another person’s beautiful. So let’s just leave it at that.

The BMW 4 Series Convertible is a great all-rounder, delivering supple comfort around town, then rewarding the enthusiastic driver with typical BMW driving dynamics beyond city limits.

Plus it has space and practicality for four. BMW has dropped the diesel engines and the petrol 430i from the range, leaving the 420i as the sensible option, then the performance pairing of the M440i and M4 Competition.

It doesn’t have too many similar-sized convertible rivals, with Audi having dropped its A5 Convertible and the Lexus LC costing over twice as much.

There is the Mercedes-Benz C-Class Cabriolet, although this has been replaced by the CLE convertible (which brings together both the C-Class and E-Class drop-tops in one model). Alternatively, there are plenty of two-seat sports convertibles on the market if you decide you don’t really need the space.

The 420i M Sport is our pick. Its 184PS petrol engine is smooth rather than exciting, but 0 to 62mph in 8.2 seconds is quick enough and the eight speed automatic suits the car well.

M Sport is already generously equipped, with 18 inch alloy wheels, heated sport seats, BMW’s Curved Display, three zone climate control, LED headlights and Parking Assistant.

M Sport Pro adds Adaptive M Suspension and sportier detailing for around £4,000 more, while the 392PS M440i xDrive brings a superb straight six engine and much stronger performance.

For most buyers, 420i M Sport offers the best balance of price, performance and equipment.

The BMW 4 Series Convertible starts at £53,835 for the 420i M Sport. M Sport Pro costs £57,835, while the M440i xDrive starts at £70,195.

That puts it close to the Mercedes CLE Cabriolet on price. The 420i M Sport looks the strongest value, while M Sport Pro is harder to justify unless you want its adaptive suspension.

The M440i is considerably more expensive, but its six cylinder engine and much stronger performance make it feel genuinely special.

The Mercedes CLE Cabriolet is the closest rival. It is more comfort focused and relaxed over long distances, while the BMW feels sharper and more rewarding to drive.

There is no direct new Audi rival, although a used Audi A5 Cabriolet remains worth considering.

If you do not need rear seats, the BMW Z4 is more focused, while the Mazda MX-5 is cheaper, lighter and more entertaining at sensible speeds. The Ford Mustang Convertible offers a very different kind of appeal, with greater emphasis on V8 character and drama.

For buyers wanting four seats, premium quality and an enjoyable drive, the real choice is between the 4 Series Convertible and Mercedes CLE Cabriolet.

What's the interior like in the BMW 4 Series?

There’s a nice, upmarket feel to both the design and the materials inside the BMW 4 Series Convertible. The leather all feels supple and comfortable, the three-tier dashboard is well laid-out, with a mixture of physical controls and the superb BMW iDrive infotainment system, and the design is practical and looks good.

If you are looking for a spacious and practical four- or five-seater, the BMW 4 Series Convertible isn't going to be a match for a BMW 3 Series saloon or BMW 4 Series Gran Coupe.

If you can do without the space they provide, the 4 Series makes for one of the most practical convertible models available, with a good interior and plenty of boot space, lots of storage cubbies around the cabin, premium build quality and a soft-top that is well insulated and easy to operate.

How easy, we hear you ask? Well, it weighs less than a folding hard-top and it will open or close in just 18 seconds at speeds up to 31mph –  ideal if you suddenly get caught in a rain shower.

It’s a multi-layer fabric roof that is great at insulating occupants from external noise when it’s closed. When it is, you get the full 385 litres of boot space, although that drops to 300 litres when the roof is stowed. That’s still considerably more than the folding hard-top of the previous-generation BMW 4 Series Convertible, which took up most of the boot.

The driving position is perfect, and when the roof is down the interior is reasonably well shielded from the wind.

The back seats are comfortable and, with a 41mm longer wheelbase than the previous generation, the legroom is sufficient for most adults, although it can be a little cramped for taller folk – and slightly claustrophobic when the roof is up.

The 420i is 4,768mm long, 1,852mm wide & 1,384mm high, with a 2,851mm wheelbase. Width including mirrors is 2,081mm. The M440i is fractionally larger at 4,770mm long and 1,394mm high, but the difference is insignificant in everyday driving.

It is a substantial car, particularly in width, so tight multi storey car parks require some care. Parking Assistant makes that easier.

BMW’s latest generation of its iDrive infotainment system is superb, with the choice of a rotary controller in the centre console or the 10.25-inch touchscreen mounted high up on the dashboard.

The screen is easy to read, with clear menus and icons, and is intuitive when it comes to navigating your way around it. Combined with the 12.3-inch digital instrument cluster, you can display audio, navigation, vehicle settings or things like the weather or news headlines.

There’s Apple CarPlay and Android Auto connectivity if you want to mirror the look and apps of your smartphone, and the BMW 4 Series Convertible has a voice assistant so you have someone to talk to when you’re alone in the car.

All models also benefit from over-the-air remote updates. It all works really well and keeps you connected, or you can just turn it all off and enjoy the drive.

Premium finishes go with the territory when you buy a BMW. The materials all feel top-notch, with soft touch plastics, neatly trimmed leather and some nicely contrasting pieces of metal or metal-look plastic. Some of the buttons in the centre of the dashboard can feel a bit loose, but generally the feeling is one of solid build quality throughout.

What's the BMW 4 Series like to drive?

The BMW 4 Series Convertible is infused with some of the typical BMW driving DNA, especially in the M440i and M4 models. The 420i provides ample power and driving fun for most, though, and even has a Sprint function to sharpen everything up when your right foot requests a sudden bit of speed. The M440i is now the pick of the range, but if you want something more aggressive and very dynamic, the M4 Competition definitely ticks those boxes. All models combine good levels of comfort with great handling. Throw in that four-seat practicality and you have a great everyday convertible.

All versions of the BMW 4 Series Convertible have petrol engines, starting with the 420i M Sport. Its maximum power of 187PS is available between 5,000-6,500rpm, with 300Nm of torque from 1350-4000rpm.

Performance is reasonable, with a 0-62mph time of 8.2 seconds. Like many BMWs, it uses the superb eight-speed Steptronic automatic gearbox with paddle shifters on the steering wheel. It’s a great engine for everyday use, but if you want something more athletic, you’ll need to look further up the range.

With the 430i convertible no longer available, it’s a big jump in price and power to the M440i xDrive, which uses 48V mild hybrid tech and has all-wheel drive.

Power is 379PS at 5,500-6,500rpm and torque is 500Nm between 1900rpm and 5000rpm, enough to give it a 0-62mph sprint time of 4.9 seconds and reach a top speed of 155mph. The 48V system also provides an additional 11PS of boost power for overtaking, or quicker acceleration from standing start.

It’s a wonderful combination, with an engine that is willing to respond instantly to acceleration requests and a chassis and suspension that allow for some enthusiastic driving, especially in one of the sportier driving modes.

At the top of the range sits the mighty BMW M4 Competition Convertible. It serves up 517PS and 650Nm of torque.

In just 3.7 seconds, you can have the wind racing through your hair at 62mph, but we don’t recommend hitting the top speed of 155mph with the top down. Adaptive suspension and various driving modes allow you to set the car up exactly the way you want, with the engine willing to be fairly docile in town, then raucous when you seek that BMW driving pleasure on the open road.

ModelEngine/battery sizePower0-62mphRange/MPG
420i
2.0 litre four cylinder petrol
184PS
8.2 seconds
Up to 41.5mpg
M440i xDrive
3.0 litre six cylinder 48V mild hybrid
392PS
4.8 seconds
Up to to 39.2mpg

The BMW 4 Series Convertible is great at delivering a rewarding drive, whether that drive is the mundane daily commute, an enthusiastic run through the countryside or enjoying a summer’s day with the top down. It’s superbly engineered to be an all-rounder and this comes through in how it drives.

All models are equipped with M Sport suspension as standard, as well as a number of driving modes. The engineers have done a fine job of keeping things comfortable, although with the top down you will feel a bit of body-flex on some bumpier back roads.

The 420i is the best if you want a daily commuter, delivering great comfort with a bit of performance. Push it hard on open roads and it will reward you with a lively and precise drive, but you won’t be surprised to find you’ll have the most fun in the M440i or M4.

Both deliver plenty of grip, while the Sport settings and active rear differential allow for some fun in the corners when you feel like being more enthusiastic. Combine that with dropping the roof and you have a performance convertible that is the best in its class – and one that is happy to let you have fun on any road.

The BMW 4 Series Convertible gets all the main safety kit, including front and side airbags, a rollover protection system and Isofix child seat anchor points.

Then there’s the electronic stuff such as Dynamic Traction Control, Cornering Brake Control and Performance Control, all of which have a range of settings to suit your driving mood.

Lane-departure warning with steering assistance is standard, as is park-distance control, autonomous emergency braking, a reversing camera and reversing assistance. It all helped gain the BMW 4 Series Convertible a five-star safety rating from Euro NCAP.

Running costs: What it's like to live with a BMW 4 Series

Running costs vary considerably by engine. The 420i can return more than 40mpg and sits in insurance groups 32 to 33, while the M440i is thirstier, more expensive to insure and likely to cost more in tyres, brakes and servicing.

The 420i returns an official 40.9 to 41.5mpg, with CO2 emissions of 154 to 158g/km. The 48V mild-hybrid M440i manages 36.7 to 39.2mpg, despite its much stronger performance, with CO2 emissions of 164 to 175g/km.

BMW provides a three-year, unlimited-mileage warranty, with roadside assistance included for the same period.

Servicing is condition based, with the car monitoring items such as engine oil and brake fluid and alerting you when maintenance is due. BMW also offers Service Inclusive packages, with current petrol-car plans starting at around £470 for three years.

The 420i M Sport sits in insurance group 32, rising to group 33 for M Sport Pro. The much quicker M440i xDrive jumps to group 42, making the 420i the more affordable choice to insure.

The BMW 4 Series Convertible costs £200 a year in standard VED after its first year. Every version also exceeds the £40,000 Expensive Car Supplement threshold, adding £440 a year for five years from the second tax payment.

That means owners pay £640 a year from years two to six, before the bill returns to the standard rate.

What trims are available with the BMW 4 Series?

The 4 Series Convertible comes in M Sport, M Sport Pro and M440i xDrive forms.

M Sport is paired with the 420i and already feels well equipped, with 18-inch alloy wheels, M styling, heated sport seats, three-zone climate control, BMW’s Curved Display and Parking Assistant.

M Sport Pro adds Adaptive M Suspension, upgraded brakes and more aggressive styling, but the £4,000 premium is difficult to justify unless those chassis upgrades matter to you.

The M440i xDrive is the performance choice, combining a 392PS straight-six mild-hybrid engine with four-wheel drive and M-specific chassis hardware.

420i M Sport is our pick. It offers the best balance of price, equipment and running costs, while the M440i makes more sense for buyers who specifically want the six-cylinder engine and extra performance.

Ask the Drive experts: common questions

The BMW 4 Series Convertible has 385 litres of boot space with the roof raised, falling to 300 litres when the roof is lowered. That is good by convertible standards.
Yes. Every 4 Series Convertible has four seats. The rear pair are useful for children and shorter adults, although tall passengers may struggle for legroom on longer journeys.
No. The current generation uses a multi layer fabric soft top rather than the folding metal roof fitted to its predecessor. It can be opened or closed electrically at speeds of up to 31mph.

Get our latest advice, news and offers

Keep me updated by email with the latest advice, news and offers from Drive.

Seat Arona in front of the Drive logo